"Utterly Ludicrous": Piers Morgan Slams Osama Claim by Pak Analyst on Live TV

British TV host Piers Morgan created a viral moment on his program "Piers Morgan Uncensored" by strongly dismissing a Pakistani analyst's assertion regarding Osama bin Laden's presence in Pakistan as "utterly ludicrous" and rekindling an old international controversy.

The fire fight broke out between Morgan and Pakistani commentator Shehzad Ghias Shaikh, who contended that the 470,000 documents uncovered by the US Navy SEAL raid on the bin Laden's Abbottabad compound showed the al-Qaeda leader was hiding actively from Pakistani intelligence, rather than being protected by them. "The Bin Laden papers were not published by Pakistan. They were published by the American intelligence.". 470,000 reports categorically report Osama bin Laden was attempting to evade Pakistani intelligence," Shaikh stated.

Morgan quickly retorted, "Sorry, for all good intentions, what you said just now is completely ridiculous. Osama bin Laden was discovered living literally in a house, within a few hundred yards of Pakistan's primary military installations.". If your intelligence did not realize that he was there, then it would be the world's worst intelligence. That's why this is a ridiculous statement". His comeback highlighted the distrust that has always hung over Pakistan's official version of events, particularly with the closeness of bin Laden's compound to a large Pakistani military base. Most Western intelligence agencies and worldwide analysts are puzzled as to how the world's most wanted terrorist was able to remain hidden for all these years in such a place.

The discussion on Morgan's program also included Indian YouTuber Ranveer Allahbadia, who held up images of Osama bin Laden and Lashkar-e-Taiba terrorist Abdul Rauf, comparing worldwide views of terrorism and defying Pakistan's narrative. Allahbadia pushed the argument that while the world knows bin Laden as a face of terror, India has a roll call of such individuals, some of whom are heroes in Pakistan, and demanded a more truthful global discourse on cross-border terrorism.

The 470,000 files, commonly called the "Bin Laden papers," have been studied for decades. Although some of the quotes reveal bin Laden's attempts to hide from detection, the reality that his compound was situated close to Pakistani military infrastructure continues to stimulate controversy and conjecture regarding potential complicity or, at the very least, egregious incompetence.

Morgan's acerbic counterattack and the wider debate serve to reinforce the long-standing suspicion between Pakistan and the West over the country's role as a haven for militants. The topic remains an international relations hot potato, especially with new discoveries and controversies over counterterrorism and intelligence failures emerging continuously.